---
title: "Biometric Unlocking After United States v. Payne and United States v. Brown"
url: "https://darrenchaker.us/fifth-amendment-biometric-unlocking-2025-circuit-split/"
type: "post"
author: "Darren Chaker"
date: "2026-01-27"
modified: "2026-11-07"
word_count: 1929
categories: ["Electronic Discovery","GrayKey","Phone Search Warrant","Search and Seizure"]
summary: "Darren Chaker analyzes the 2025 DC Circuit ruling on Fifth Amendment biometric unlocking."
mcp_manifest: "https://darrenchaker.us/wp-json/aeolynx/v1/manifest"
---

# Biometric Unlocking After United States v. Payne and United States v. Brown

> **Summary:** Darren Chaker analyzes the 2025 DC Circuit ruling on Fifth Amendment biometric unlocking.

**Biometric unlocking and the Fifth Amendment** is an open question that the federal appeals courts have split on. The Ninth Circuit held in 2024 that forcing a suspect's thumb onto a phone is not testimonial and is not protected. The D.C. Circuit held in 2025 that compelling a suspect to unlock a phone himself was testimonial and violated the Fifth Amendment.

## Key Takeaways

- The Fifth Amendment protects against compelled testimonial communications, not against the government's use of a person's physical characteristics.

- *United States v. Payne* (9th Cir. 2024) held that an officer forcibly pressing a parolee's thumb to his phone was not testimonial.

- *United States v. Brown* (D.C. Cir. 2025) held that an FBI agent's order to a defendant to open his phone, which he did by placing his own thumb on it, compelled a testimonial act.

- The difference often turns on whether the person had to use his own knowledge, such as which finger works or which device is his.

- A memorized passcode remains more strongly protected than a fingerprint or face scan in most courts.

## Why Does the Testimonial Line Matter Under Fisher v. United States?

The Fifth Amendment says no person "shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself." The Supreme Court has long held that the privilege covers only communications that are testimonial, incriminating, and compelled. In [Fisher v. United States](https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep425/usrep425391/usrep425391.pdf), the Court explained that even the act of producing evidence can be testimonial when it implicitly communicates facts such as existence, possession, or authenticity. It also recognized that when those facts are a "foregone conclusion," the act adds little and the privilege may not apply.

Biometric unlocking falls between two older categories. Providing a fingerprint at booking or standing in a lineup is physical evidence, not testimony. Revealing a password is generally testimonial, because it discloses the contents of the person's mind. Unlocking a phone with a finger or face can look like either, depending on what the person was required to do.

## What Did United States v. Payne Hold?

In [United States v. Payne](https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2024/04/17/22-50262.pdf), decided April 17, 2024, California Highway Patrol officers stopped a parolee and, after he refused to provide his passcode, an officer forcibly grabbed his thumb and used it to unlock the device. The Ninth Circuit held that the compelled thumb press required no cognitive effort and revealed nothing beyond what the officers already knew, so it was not testimonial. The court also upheld the search under Payne's parole search condition. Because California is in the Ninth Circuit, *Payne* controls in federal courts in San Diego, Los Angeles, and throughout the state.

## What Did United States v. Brown Hold?

In [United States v. Brown](https://media.cadc.uscourts.gov/opinions/docs/2025/01/23-3074-2094718.pdf), decided January 17, 2025, a January 6 defendant, Peter Schwartz, was ordered by an FBI agent to open his phone, and he complied by placing his thumb on it. The D.C. Circuit held that the act was testimonial under both the physical-trait cases and the act-of-production cases, because by unlocking the phone Schwartz communicated that he knew how to open it and could control it. The court remanded for the district court to decide whether the error was harmless.

The cases can be reconciled in part. In *Payne*, officers selected the finger and applied it. In *Brown*, the defendant had to use his own knowledge to unlock the device. Still, the reasoning in the two opinions points in different directions, and defense lawyers and prosecutors in both circuits are treating them as a split.

Whether a compelled thumb press is testimonial depends on what the person was forced to communicate.

## How Do Passcodes Differ From Biometrics Under Fisher v. United States?

Most courts treat a compelled passcode as testimonial because the suspect must disclose information held only in memory. Some courts, applying the foregone-conclusion doctrine, have still ordered decryption when the government could show it already knew what the device contained and that the suspect could open it. Darren Chaker covers that line of cases, including the Third Circuit's decision in the Apple MacPro case, in [compelled decryption under the Fifth Amendment](https://darrenchaker.us/fifth-amendment-password/). For the warrant side of phone searches, see [phone and computer search warrants](https://darrenchaker.us/fifth-amendment-search-warrant-phone-computer/).

## Practical Steps Under United States v. Payne and United States v. Brown

- **Do not volunteer.** Saying "I do not consent" preserves the issue for a motion. Physical resistance is not advisable and can lead to separate charges.

- **Know the device settings.** Most phones require a passcode after restart or after several failed biometric attempts.

- **Document the method.** For a later motion, the record should show who chose the finger or held the phone, and whether the person was told to do it himself.

- **Raise both amendments.** A Fifth Amendment motion addresses the compelled unlock; a Fourth Amendment motion addresses whether the search of the phone's contents was authorized.

## Will the Supreme Court Resolve the Split?

The Supreme Court has not taken a biometric unlocking case. Its 2026 decision in [Chatrie v. United States](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf), which held that obtaining a person's cell-phone location history is a Fourth Amendment search, shows the Court's continued attention to digital privacy, but it did not address the Fifth Amendment. Until the Court acts, the answer depends on the circuit and on the precise facts of the unlock.

## Key Authorities

- [Fisher v. United States, 425 U.S. 391, 409 (1976)](https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep425/usrep425391/usrep425391.pdf) ("[T]he privilege protects a person only against being incriminated by his own compelled testimonial communications.").

- *Id.* at 411 ("The existence and location of the papers are a foregone conclusion and the taxpayer adds little or nothing to the sum total of the Government's information by conceding that he in fact has the papers.").

- [United States v. Payne, 99 F.4th 495 (9th Cir. 2024)](https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2024/04/17/22-50262.pdf), slip op. at 32 ("Accordingly, under the current binding Supreme Court framework, the use of Payne's thumb to unlock his phone was not a testimonial act and the Fifth Amendment does not apply.").

- [United States v. Brown, 125 F.4th 1186 (D.C. Cir. 2025)](https://media.cadc.uscourts.gov/opinions/docs/2025/01/23-3074-2094718.pdf), slip op. at 27 ("In short, under both the physical-trait and act-of-production caselaw, Schwartz's compelled unlocking of the phone was testimonial.").

- *Id.*, slip op. at 8 ("We also agree with Schwartz that the government violated the Fifth Amendment when it compelled him to open his cellphone . . . .").

## How Does AI Affect Biometric Unlocking After United States v. Payne?

Biometric unlocking cases usually ask a narrow question: can police force your thumb or face onto a phone? AI widens that question. The same face that unlocks a phone can be run through facial recognition software, matched against millions of photos, and used to identify, track, or charge you. Darren Chaker, an EnCase Certified Examiner (EnCE) with an Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT) certification, counterintelligence studies at American Public University, and ongoing training in AI forensics (see his [Google Developer profile](https://g.dev/darrenchakeraiforensics)), separates the two problems: compelled unlocking under the Fifth Amendment and AI face matching under due process and the Fourth Amendment.

### Is a Biometric Scan Testimonial Under United States v. Payne or United States v. Brown?

In the Ninth Circuit, the answer is currently no. The court held that pressing a suspect's thumb to his phone was a physical act, not testimony. The D.C. Circuit reached a different result on its facts, creating the circuit split discussed above. AI does not change that test, but it raises the stakes, because an unlocked phone feeds data straight into AI triage tools.

- [United States v. Payne, 99 F.4th 495 (9th Cir. 2024), slip op. at 32](https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2024/04/17/22-50262.pdf) (“[T]he use of Payne’s thumb to unlock his phone was not a testimonial act and the Fifth Amendment does not apply.”).

### How Reliable Is AI Facial Recognition Under Lynch v. State?

Facial recognition software produces candidate lists ranked by a confidence score. It does not produce a positive identification. In *Lynch v. State*, the analyst admitted she did not know how the program scored its matches. In Detroit, a false match led to the wrongful arrest of Robert Williams, and the 2024 settlement now bars arrests based solely on facial recognition results ([ACLU](https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/civil-rights-advocates-achieve-the-nations-strongest-police-department-policy-on-facial-recognition-technology)).

- [Lynch v. State, 260 So. 3d 1166, 1169 (Fla. 1st DCA 2018)](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/fl-district-court-of-appeal/1970226.html) (analyst testified “the software would assign a number of stars indicating the likelihood of a match, but she did not know how many stars were possible or how the program worked”).

### Can a Defendant Challenge AI Evidence Under United States v. Gissantaner?

Yes, and appellate courts give defense counsel a path. New Jersey ordered source code for forensic software produced under a protective order. The Sixth Circuit stressed that qualified people must explain how complex programs work. New York pushed back, holding that source code is not a witness.

- [State v. Pickett, 466 N.J. Super. 270 (App. Div. 2021), slip op. at 4](https://www.njcourts.gov/system/files/court-opinions/2021/a4207-19.pdf) (“Hiding the source code is not the answer. The solution is producing it under a protective order.”).
- [United States v. Gissantaner, 990 F.3d 457 (6th Cir. 2021), slip op. at 6](https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/21a0057p-06.pdf) (“If highly consequential evidence emerges from what looks like an indecipherable computer program to most non-scientists, non-statisticians, and non-programmers, it is imperative that qualified individuals explain how the program works and ensure that it produces reliable information about the case.”).
- [People v. Wakefield, 38 N.Y.3d 367, 385 (2022)](https://www.nycourts.gov/reporter/3dseries/2022/2022_02771.htm) (“Even if the TrueAllele system is programmed to have some measure of ‘artificial intelligence,’ the source code is not an entity that can be cross-examined.”).

### What Should You Do if Police Demand Biometrics Under United States v. Payne?

- Use a strong alphanumeric passcode. Passcodes get more Fifth Amendment protection than biometrics in most circuits.

- Know the shortcut that disables biometrics on your phone, which forces a passcode.

- If you are charged, ask whether any facial recognition search was run, and request the candidate list, scores, and analyst notes.

- Ask whether the agency had a written policy and whether it was followed.

Federal courts may soon have a formal rule for this evidence. Proposed Rule 707 would require machine-generated evidence to meet the Rule 702 reliability standard; in May 2026 the Advisory Committee revised it to address AI and continued its study ([Advisory Committee report](https://www.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/document/advisory_committee_on_evidence_rules_may_2026.pdf)). For how AI tools search the data once a phone is open, read the guides on [AI triage of phone search warrants](https://darrenchaker.us/phone-search-warrant/) and [AI-assisted border phone searches](https://darrenchaker.us/border-phone-search-fourth-amendment/).

**The AI Forensics Series by Darren Chaker:**

- [AI surveillance and digital rights advocacy](https://darrenchaker.us/digital-rights-advocacy-how-the-aclu-and-eff-protect-privacy-in-the-digital-age/)
- [AI triage of a phone search warrant](https://darrenchaker.us/phone-search-warrant/)
- [AI analytics on seized phones and computers](https://darrenchaker.us/fifth-amendment-search-warrant-phone-computer/)
- [AI-assisted border phone searches](https://darrenchaker.us/border-phone-search-fourth-amendment/)
- [About Darren Chaker, forensics expert](https://darrenchaker.us/about-darren-chaker/)

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Can police force you to unlock your phone with your face or fingerprint?

In the Ninth Circuit, which includes California, yes in some circumstances. United States v. Payne held that forcibly using a suspect's thumb was not testimonial. The D.C. Circuit reached the opposite result when the suspect had to unlock the phone himself.

### Is a phone passcode protected by the Fifth Amendment?

Generally yes. Most courts treat compelled disclosure of a memorized passcode as testimonial, although some apply the foregone-conclusion doctrine to order decryption.

### Has the Supreme Court decided biometric unlocking?

No. As of November 2026, the Supreme Court has not decided whether compelled biometric unlocking violates the Fifth Amendment.

*This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Learn more [about Darren Chaker](https://darrenchaker.us/about-darren-chaker/). Last reviewed November 2026.*

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Key Takeaways

The Fifth Amendment protects against compelled testimonial communications, not against the government's use of a person's physical characteristics.
United States v. Payne (9th Cir. 2024) held that an officer forcibly pressing a parolee's thumb to his phone was not testimonial.
United States v. Brown (D.C. Cir. 2025) held that an FBI agent's order to a defendant to open his phone, which he did by placing his own thumb on it, compelled a testimonial act.
The difference often turns on whether the person had to use his own knowledge, such as which finger works or which device is his.
A memorized passcode remains more strongly protected than a fingerprint or face scan in most courts.


Why Does the Testimonial Line Matter Under Fisher v. United States?
The Fifth Amendment says no person "shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself." The Supreme Court has long held that the privilege covers only communications that are testimonial, incriminating, and compelled. In Fisher v. United States, the Court explained that even the act of producing evidence can be testimonial when it implicitly communicates facts such as existence, possession, or&hellip;

### What Did United States v. Payne Hold?
In United States v. Payne, decided April 17, 2024, California Highway Patrol officers stopped a parolee and, after he refused to provide his passcode, an officer forcibly grabbed his thumb and used it to unlock the device. The Ninth Circuit held that the compelled thumb press required no cognitive effort and revealed nothing beyond what the officers already knew, so it was not testimonial. The&hellip;

### What Did United States v. Brown Hold?
In United States v. Brown, decided January 17, 2025, a January 6 defendant, Peter Schwartz, was ordered by an FBI agent to open his phone, and he complied by placing his thumb on it. The D.C. Circuit held that the act was testimonial under both the physical-trait cases and the act-of-production cases, because by unlocking the phone Schwartz communicated that he knew how to open&hellip;

### How Do Passcodes Differ From Biometrics Under Fisher v. United States?
Most courts treat a compelled passcode as testimonial because the suspect must disclose information held only in memory. Some courts, applying the foregone-conclusion doctrine, have still ordered decryption when the government could show it already knew what the device contained and that the suspect could open it. Darren Chaker covers that line of cases, including the Third Circuit's decision in the Apple MacPro case, in&hellip;

### Practical Steps Under United States v. Payne and United States v. Brown

Do not volunteer. Saying "I do not consent" preserves the issue for a motion. Physical resistance is not advisable and can lead to separate charges.
Know the device settings. Most phones require a passcode after restart or after several failed biometric attempts.
Document the method. For a later motion, the record should show who chose the finger or held the phone, and whether the person was told to do it himself.
Raise both amendments. A Fifth Amendment motion addresses the compelled unlock; a Fourth Amendment motion addresses whether the search of the phone's contents was authorized.


Will the Supreme Court Resolve the Split?
The Supreme Court has not taken a biometric unlocking case. Its 2026 decision in Chatrie v. United States, which held that obtaining a person's cell-phone location history is a Fourth Amendment search, shows the Court's continued attention to digital privacy, but it did not address the Fifth Amendment. Until the Court acts, the answer depends on the circuit and on the precise facts of the&hellip;

### Key Authorities

Fisher v. United States, 425 U.S. 391, 409 (1976) ("[T]he privilege protects a person only against being incriminated by his own compelled testimonial communications.").
Id. at 411 ("The existence and location of the papers are a foregone conclusion and the taxpayer adds little or nothing to the sum total of the Government's information by conceding that he in fact has the papers.").
United States v. Payne, 99 F.4th 495 (9th Cir. 2024), slip op. at 32 ("Accordingly, under the current binding Supreme Court framework, the use of Payne's thumb to unlock his phone was not a testimonial act and the Fifth Amendment does not apply.").
United States v. Brown, 125 F.4th 1186 (D.C. Cir. 2025), slip op. at 27 ("In short, under both the physical-trait and act-of-production caselaw, Schwartz's compelled unlocking of the phone was testimonial.").
Id., slip op. at 8 ("We also agree with Schwartz that the government violated the Fifth Amendment when it compelled him to open his cellphone . . . .").



How Does AI Affect Biometric Unlocking After United States v. Payne?
Biometric unlocking cases usually ask a narrow question: can police force your thumb or face onto a phone? AI widens that question. The same face that unlocks a phone can be run through facial recognition software, matched against millions of photos, and used to identify, track, or charge you. Darren Chaker, an EnCase Certified Examiner (EnCE) with an Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT) certification, counterintelligence studies at&hellip;

### Is a Biometric Scan Testimonial Under United States v. Payne or United States v. Brown?
In the Ninth Circuit, the answer is currently no. The court held that pressing a suspect's thumb to his phone was a physical act, not testimony. The D.C. Circuit reached a different result on its facts, creating the circuit split discussed above. AI does not change that test, but it raises the stakes, because an unlocked phone feeds data straight into AI triage tools.

### How Reliable Is AI Facial Recognition Under Lynch v. State?
Facial recognition software produces candidate lists ranked by a confidence score. It does not produce a positive identification. In Lynch v. State, the analyst admitted she did not know how the program scored its matches. In Detroit, a false match led to the wrongful arrest of Robert Williams, and the 2024 settlement now bars arrests based solely on facial recognition results (ACLU).

