Obsidian Finance Group, LLC v. Cox: Blogger First Amendment Rights

Laptop displaying a blog beside a pocket U.S. Constitution, representing blogger <a href=First Amendment rights" width="1536" height="864" />
Courts apply the same First Amendment protections to bloggers that they apply to professional journalists.

Blogger First Amendment rights are the same rights the Constitution gives any other speaker. The Ninth Circuit has held that a blogger cannot be held liable for defamation on a matter of public concern without proof of fault, and in United States v. Chaker it reversed a supervised-release revocation that rested on a blog post the government never proved was false, malicious, or intended to harass.

Key Takeaways

  • In Obsidian Finance Group v. Cox (2014), the Ninth Circuit held that First Amendment defamation protections do not depend on whether the speaker is a “journalist.”
  • In United States v. Chaker (2016), the Ninth Circuit reversed a revocation of Darren Chaker’s supervised release that was based on a blog post.
  • Labeling speech “harassment” or “defamation” does not relieve the government of its burden to prove the actual elements, including falsity and actual malice.
  • For threats, Counterman v. Colorado (2023) requires proof that the speaker at least recklessly disregarded the threatening nature of the words.

Do Bloggers Have the Same First Amendment Rights as Journalists Under Obsidian Finance Group, LLC v. Cox?

Yes. Courts have refused to create a two-tier system in which institutional media receive stronger protection than independent writers. In Obsidian Finance Group, LLC v. Cox, a jury had returned a large defamation verdict against a blogger, and the trial court had ruled she was not entitled to the protections that apply to media defendants. The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding that the negligence and actual-malice rules of Gertz v. Robert Welch, Inc. apply to individual speakers as well. The opinion is posted on the Ninth Circuit’s website.

The practical rule is straightforward. When a blog post addresses a matter of public concern, a plaintiff must prove fault. To recover presumed damages, the plaintiff must prove actual malice, meaning knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.

What Happened in United States v. Chaker?

Darren Chaker was serving a term of federal supervised release with a special condition that barred stalking or harassment, including “defaming a person’s character on the internet.” The government sought revocation based on a blog post that referred to another individual, and the district court revoked supervision and imposed a new sentence.

On appeal, the Ninth Circuit reversed the revocation and vacated the sentence. The panel found that the post was not directed at the person in question, that the government failed to prove intent to harass, and that the government also failed to prove the elements of defamation, including falsity and actual malice. Because it decided the appeal on those grounds, the court did not reach Chaker’s constitutional arguments. The memorandum disposition is available from the Ninth Circuit. As an unpublished memorandum, it is not binding precedent under Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3, but it shows how the court applies settled defamation elements to online speech.

Why Supervised-Release Conditions Must Track United States v. Chaker

A supervised-release condition that forbids “defaming” someone online imports the entire body of defamation law into a revocation hearing. The government cannot simply show that a post was unflattering. It must prove a false statement of fact, and where the subject is a public matter, the constitutionally required level of fault. The Chaker memorandum applied exactly that framework, and the revocation failed because the proof did not meet it.

The same principle limits overbroad conditions generally. The Ninth Circuit has vacated internet bans that sweep far beyond what is needed to protect the public, as discussed in Darren Chaker’s analysis of overbroad probation conditions.

Where Is the Line Between Criticism and a True Threat Under Counterman v. Colorado?

Harsh criticism, ridicule, and opinion are protected. True threats are not. In Counterman v. Colorado, the Supreme Court held that the government must prove the speaker had some subjective understanding of the threatening character of the statements, and that recklessness is enough. That mental-state requirement gives speakers breathing room, which is particularly important for bloggers who write about public officials, litigants, and public controversies. The opinion is posted on the Supreme Court’s website.

Key Authorities

  • Obsidian Fin. Grp., LLC v. Cox, 740 F.3d 1284 (9th Cir. 2014), slip op. at 3 (“We hold that liability for a defamatory blog post involving a matter of public concern cannot be imposed without proof of fault and actual damages.”).
  • Id., slip op. at 11–12 (“The protections of the First Amendment do not turn on whether the defendant was a trained journalist, formally affiliated with traditional news entities, engaged in conflict-of-interest disclosure, went beyond just assembling others’ writings, or tried to get both sides of a story.”).
  • United States v. Chaker, Nos. 15-50138, 15-50193, slip op. at 2 (9th Cir. July 6, 2016) (mem.) (“The government also failed to prove that Chaker’s blog post satisfied the elements of defamation, including falsity and actual malice.”).
  • Id., slip op. at 1 (“We reverse the revocation of Chaker’s supervised release and vacate the sentence imposed.”).
  • Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), slip op. at 1 (“The State must show that the defendant consciously disregarded a substantial risk that his communications would be viewed as threatening violence.”).

Practical Guidance for Bloggers Under Obsidian Finance Group, LLC v. Cox

  • Separate verifiable facts from opinion, and link to the public records that support each fact.
  • Write about conduct and public issues rather than private details that serve no public purpose.
  • Keep source documents, such as court filings and public records, in case a statement is challenged.
  • Correct genuine factual errors promptly; doing so is evidence of good faith.

For more on how courts treat online speech, see cyberstalking laws and First Amendment defenses and the landmark decision in Chaker v. Crogan.

Can a Blogger Publish Anonymously Under McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Comm’n?

Yes, in most settings. The Supreme Court has long treated anonymous and pseudonymous writing as part of the American tradition of political pamphleteering. Courts may unmask an anonymous speaker in a defamation case, but most apply a heightened showing before they do, and Darren Chaker covers that standard in his discussion of anonymous speech rights.

How Should a Blogger Respond to a Defamation Demand Letter Under Obsidian Finance Group, LLC v. Cox?

A demand letter is often the first step in an effort to remove criticism. Darren Chaker’s own litigation history, including the Ninth Circuit’s 2016 decision in United States v. Chaker, shows why the response should be measured and documented.

  1. Preserve everything. Save the post, its revision history, publication dates, and the letter itself.
  2. Separate fact from opinion. Statements of opinion and rhetorical hyperbole are generally protected; provably false statements of fact are not.
  3. Identify your sources. Court records, public filings, and official reports support truth and fair-report defenses.
  4. Evaluate anti-SLAPP protection. In California, Code of Civil Procedure § 425.16 allows an early motion to strike claims arising from speech on a public issue.
  5. Correct genuine errors promptly. A visible correction can reduce exposure and strengthens credibility.
  6. Consult counsel before removing content. Removal is a choice, not an admission, but it should be a considered one.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a blogger be sued for defamation?

Yes, but on matters of public concern the plaintiff must prove fault, and presumed damages require actual malice under Obsidian Finance Group v. Cox.

What did the Ninth Circuit decide in United States v. Chaker?

It reversed the revocation of Darren Chaker’s supervised release and vacated the sentence because the government did not prove intent to harass or the elements of defamation.

Is a harsh blog post a true threat?

Not by itself. Under Counterman v. Colorado, the government must prove the speaker at least recklessly disregarded that the words would be seen as threatening violence.

Can the Darren Chaker blogging case help other bloggers?

Yes. United States v. Chaker shows that a court cannot treat critical blog posts as a supervised-release violation without finding the speech falls into an unprotected category such as defamation made with actual malice.

Do bloggers have a right to stay anonymous?

Generally yes. McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission recognizes anonymous speech as protected, although courts may order disclosure in a defamation case after the plaintiff makes a sufficient showing.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Learn more about Darren Chaker. Last reviewed November 2026.

Darren Chaker

Darren Chaker

For almost two decades Darren Chaker regularly has worked with defense attorneys and high net worth people on a variety of sensitive issues from Los Angeles to Dubai. With a gift of knowledge about the First Amendment and big firm expertise in brief research and writing, Darren Chaker puts his knowledge to use for law firms and non-profit organizations.