District of Columbia v. Wesby: Probable Cause to Arrest Explained

Police patrol car light bar glowing on a wet city street at night, illustrating probable cause to arrest
Probable cause to arrest is judged by the totality of the circumstances known to the officer at the time

Probable cause to arrest exists when the facts and circumstances known to an officer would lead a prudent person to conclude there is a fair probability that the suspect committed a crime. The Supreme Court has said the standard “is not a high bar,” but it still requires specific facts, not hunches, and it is measured by the totality of the circumstances at the moment of arrest.

Reviewed and updated November 9, 2026. Darren Chaker, a San Diego legal research specialist who reviews arrest reports and court records, updated this post with the Supreme Court’s 2026 totality-of-the-circumstances ruling.

Key Takeaways

  • Probable cause requires a probability or substantial chance of criminal activity, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt or even a preponderance.
  • Courts evaluate the totality of the circumstances, including innocent-looking facts that become suspicious in context.
  • In California, Penal Code § 836 governs when officers may arrest without a warrant.
  • Probable cause generally defeats a First Amendment retaliatory-arrest claim, subject to a narrow exception recognized in Nieves v. Bartlett and clarified in Gonzalez v. Trevino.

What Is the Legal Standard for Probable Cause to Arrest Under District of Columbia v. Wesby?

The Fourth Amendment allows a warrantless arrest in public when an officer has probable cause to believe the person committed a crime. In District of Columbia v. Wesby, officers arrested partygoers found in a vacant house. The Supreme Court held the officers had probable cause for trespass because the totality of the circumstances, including the condition of the house, the partygoers’ conduct, and their vague and conflicting explanations, made it reasonable to infer they knew they lacked permission. The Court criticized the lower court for viewing each fact in isolation. The opinion is on the Supreme Court’s website.

How Is Probable Cause Different From Reasonable Suspicion?

Reasonable suspicion, which justifies a brief investigative stop, requires specific and articulable facts suggesting criminal activity may be afoot. Probable cause, which justifies an arrest or a search warrant, requires a fair probability. Both standards are practical and flexible, but probable cause demands more. For a full comparison, see Darren Chaker’s guide to probable cause versus reasonable suspicion.

How Does the Ninth Circuit Apply the Standard in United States v. Hamilton?

The Ninth Circuit applied these principles in United States v. Hamilton (2025). Officers investigating a recent shooting approached Hamilton, identified themselves, and ordered him to stop. He ran and reached toward his waistband. The court held that the investigation linking him to the shooting, his flight, and his movement toward his waistband together supplied probable cause. The court also cautioned that flight is not automatically suspicious, because some people run for innocent reasons. The opinion is available from the Ninth Circuit.

When Can California Officers Arrest Without a Warrant Under Penal Code § 836?

Under Penal Code § 836, a peace officer may arrest without a warrant when the officer has probable cause to believe the person committed a public offense in the officer’s presence, when the person has committed a felony even if not in the officer’s presence, or when the officer has probable cause to believe the person committed a felony. The statute also contains specific provisions for domestic violence and certain misdemeanors committed outside the officer’s presence.

Does Probable Cause Defeat a Retaliatory Arrest Claim Under Nieves v. Bartlett?

Usually, yes. In Nieves v. Bartlett, the Supreme Court held that a plaintiff claiming an arrest was in retaliation for protected speech must generally plead and prove the absence of probable cause. The Court recognized an exception when the plaintiff produces objective evidence that similarly situated people who did not engage in the same speech were not arrested. In Gonzalez v. Trevino, the Court held that the exception does not require nearly identical comparators, and that other objective evidence, such as a survey of prior charges, may qualify. Both opinions are on the Supreme Court’s website: Nieves and Gonzalez.

These decisions matter for journalists, protesters, and critics of government who are arrested for minor offenses after speaking out, an issue closely related to the viewpoint-discrimination principles in Chaker v. Crogan.

Key Authorities

  • District of Columbia v. Wesby, 583 U.S. 48 (2018), slip op. at 7 (Probable cause “requires only a probability or substantial chance of criminal activity, not an actual showing of such activity.”).
  • Id., slip op. at 7 (“Probable cause ‘is not a high bar.'”).
  • United States v. Hamilton, No. 22-10161, slip op. at 14 (9th Cir. Mar. 24, 2025) (probable cause exists where, “under the totality of the facts and circumstances known to the arresting officer, a prudent person would have concluded that there was a fair probability that the suspect had committed a crime”).
  • Id., slip op. at 14 (“[F]light is not per se suspicious.”).
  • Nieves v. Bartlett, 587 U.S. 391 (2019), slip op. at 9 (“The plaintiff pressing a retaliatory arrest claim must plead and prove the absence of probable cause for the arrest.”).
  • Gonzalez v. Trevino, 602 U.S. 653 (2024) (per curiam), slip op. at 4 (“Although the Nieves exception is slim, the demand for virtually identical and identifiable comparators goes too far.”).

Common Probable Cause Issues in Practice

  • Informant tips. Courts weigh the informant’s reliability and basis of knowledge, and whether police corroborated the details. See confidential informant reliability.
  • Collective knowledge. Officers may rely on information known to the team, not only to the arresting officer.
  • Mistakes of fact. A reasonable factual mistake does not necessarily defeat probable cause.
  • Timing. Facts learned after the arrest cannot be used to justify it.

How Does Probable Cause to Arrest Compare With Other Standards?

Police action Standard Leading case
Brief investigative stop Reasonable suspicion Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968)
Arrest Probable cause Maryland v. Pringle, 540 U.S. 366 (2003)
Search of a home Probable cause and a warrant Payton v. New York, 445 U.S. 573 (1980)

Can police arrest someone for a very minor offense?

Yes, under the Fourth Amendment. “If an officer has probable cause to believe that an individual has committed even a very minor criminal offense in his presence, he may, without violating the Fourth Amendment, arrest the offender.” Atwater v. City of Lago Vista, 532 U.S. 318, 354 (2001). California statutes, however, add their own limits on custodial arrests for infractions.

Can probable cause be measured as a percentage?

No. “The probable-cause standard is incapable of precise definition or quantification into percentages because it deals with probabilities and depends on the totality of the circumstances.” Maryland v. Pringle, 540 U.S. 366, 371 (2003). In 2026, the Court repeated that courts may not evaluate and reject facts “in isolation from each other.” District of Columbia v. R.W., No. 25-248, slip op. at 2 (U.S. Apr. 20, 2026) (per curiam).

For the lower standard, see probable cause vs reasonable suspicion.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is probable cause to arrest?

A fair probability, based on the totality of the circumstances known to the officer, that the person committed a crime.

Is probable cause the same as reasonable suspicion?

No. Reasonable suspicion supports a brief stop; probable cause, a higher standard, is required for an arrest.

Can I sue if I was arrested for my speech?

You generally must show the arrest lacked probable cause, unless you have objective evidence that others in similar situations who did not speak were not arrested (Nieves; Gonzalez).

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Learn more about Darren Chaker. Last reviewed November 2026.

Darren Chaker

Darren Chaker

For almost two decades Darren Chaker regularly has worked with defense attorneys and high net worth people on a variety of sensitive issues from Los Angeles to Dubai. With a gift of knowledge about the First Amendment and big firm expertise in brief research and writing, Darren Chaker puts his knowledge to use for law firms and non-profit organizations.

Related Reading

Browse more of Darren Chaker's analysis on constitutional rights, policing, and free speech.